census.gov Notification
Due to the lapse of federal funding, portions of this website are not being updated. Any inquiries submitted via www.census.gov will not be answered until appropriations are enacted.

Comparison of Local Powers of Some Exact Tests for a Common Normal Mean with Unequal Variances

Written by:
RRS2020-02

Abstract

The inferential problem of drawing inference about a common mean µ of several independent normal populations with unequal variances has drawn universal attention, and there are many exact and asymptotic tests for testing a null hypothesis H0 : µ = µ0 against two-sided alternatives. In this paper we provide a review of some of these exact and asymptotic tests, and present theoretical expressions of local powers of the exact tests and a comparison. It turns out that, in the case of equal sample size, a uniform comparison and ordering of the exact tests based on their local power can be carried out even when the variances are unknown. Our observation is that both modified F and modified t tests based on a suitable combination of component F and t statistics perform the best in terms of local power among all exact tests under consideration. An exact test based on inverse normal method of combination of P-values also performs reasonably well.

Page Last Revised - October 8, 2021